|
Charlotte News and Observer September 24, 2008
Stem Cell Research is a Weapon in Governor's Race
Mark Johnson, Staff Writer
RALEIGH - The campaign for governor is being waged with a wheelchair and dead parents.The
Democratic and Republican candidates are rolling out emotional tales
and images to jab each other over embryonic stem cell research, a
complex scientific and moral question of life-saving cures versus
snuffing out life. The debate, oddly timed given that voters are
sweating a national economic meltdown, may appear to fall under
Washington's jurisdiction. State governments, though, have increasingly
provided the arena for settling the issue. Lt. Gov. Beverly
Perdue, the Democratic candidate, recently deployed a television ad
featuring Sarah Witt of Raleigh, a former marathon runner now paralyzed
by a neurological disease, who speaks from a wheelchair, with the aid
of an electronic voice box. Witt criticizes the Republican nominee,
Charlotte Mayor Pat McCrory, for opposing embryonic stem cell research. "A
motor neuron disease has already taken away my ability to walk and to
speak, but it hasn't taken away my ability to hope. Hope that stem cell
research will let me see my kids grow up," Witt says. "How can he be
against hope?" The ad is part of Perdue's continuing effort to paint McCrory as an extreme conservative. McCrory
returned fire with an ad featuring his sister, Linda Sebastian, who
scolds Perdue for suggesting McCrory is insensitive to suffering and
highlights that their parents died of "long illnesses" -- Alzheimer's
disease and non-Hodgkin lymphoma. "Using a victim of terrible
disease for political gain is shameful. Pat McCrory supports stem cell
research when a human embryo is not destroyed," Sebastian said in the
ad, referring to advancements made in research using non- embryonic
stem cells, such as those derived from human skin. McCrory's
strategist, Jack Hawke, said Monday that McCrory would sign a bill that
banned embryonic stem cell research. On Tuesday, though, McCrory was
less definitive. "I don't know the details of what we can do now enough to know," McCrory said. "I'd have to get back to you on that." Perdue,
on the other hand, is stoking an issue on which she has previously
played no visible role. Her campaign could not provide a public
statement she has made on the issue before the campaign. Rep.
Earl Jones, a Greensboro Democrat who sponsored a bill for stem cell
funding last year, said he didn't hear from Perdue until after it
passed the House, even though the funding would come through the Health
& Wellness Trust Fund of which she is the chairwoman. But he said
she stepped in once it reached the Senate, where it never got out of
committee. "She was the first person to call me," he said. "She wanted to know what she could do." Stem cells' promise Embryonic
stem cells are derived from the inside of a fertilized human egg,
usually from a fertilization clinic. Stem cells can develop specialized
cells from which various human tissues form and can renew themselves.
Scientists are using them to try and cure currently incurable diseases
such as Alzheimer's and Parkinson's. Opponents condemn the research as
destroying a human life, but supporters argue that the embryos used are
those that fertility clinics are going to destroy anyway. Congress
and President Bush banned federal funding for research on new lines of
embryonic stem cells in 2001 but didn't ban the research itself. That
left the opportunity for private institutions and states to step in,
prompting debates and either bans against, or funding for, the research. Perdue
said she would push for state funding for embryonic stem cell research
and that voters will pay attention to the issue, even in the midst of
the dire financial news. "I think the people of the state are eat
up right now, as I am, with concern over the economy and the future,"
Perdue said last week. "But they also, if they've got a quadriplegic or
a kid who has severe diabetes, they worry about how they can help that
kid live or function longer." McCrory's campaign said he supports
stem cell research from non-controversial sources, which shows
increasing promise for results, but Hawke said McCrory would support a
ban on embryonic research. States' actions North
Carolina's legislature has not considered a ban. The state House passed
a bill last year providing state funding that the Senate never
considered. At least six states -- Arkansas, Indiana, Louisiana,
Michigan, North Dakota and South Dakota -- have banned stem cell
research that involves the destruction of an embryo, according to
stateline.org, a nonprofit group that monitors the workings of state
governments. Seven other states have invested funding in the
research: California, Connecticut, Illinois, Maryland, New Jersey, New
York and Wisconsin. Three states -- Iowa, Massachusetts and Missouri --
have re-established or underscored the legality of the research,
according to stateline. In 2006 and 2007, states awarded $230
million in grants for stem cell research. Last year, New York and
Illinois cleared the way for state funding, while Iowa overturned its
ban. Michigan voters will decide in November whether to overturn that
state's ban
|